Best Catcher’s Mitt for Sale in 2018

From their playing position, catchers are the only players who face the rest of the players for the whole game. While communicating strategy with the pitcher, they have to catch the ball quickly and securely to be ready for any potential base stealers. Catchers need a mitt that provides them with the ultimate ball control.

We will be discussing the features that you need to consider to select the best catchers mitt for yourself or your child. Then, we will review different adult and youth baseball catchers mitts and fastpitch softball catchers mitts.

We will be reviewing the following ten best catchers mitts for sale:

  • AllStar CM3000SBT 33.5" Catchers Mitt
  • Wilson A2000 CM33 33" Baseball Catcher's Mitt
  • Mizuno 34" World Win GXC75 Catcher's Mitt
  • Mizuno Samurai Catchers Baseball Mitt
  • Mizuno Franchise GXC90B2 33.5" Left-handed Thrower Adult Baseball Catcher's Mitt
  • Rawlings Gamer Youth Pro Taper Glove Series
  • Mizuno Prospect GXC105 Youth Baseball Catchers Mitt
  • Mizuno Franchise Fastpitch Series 34" Catchers Mitt
  • Easton Core Pro Fastpitch Mitt
  • Mizuno Prospect GXS101 Youth Fastpitch Catchers Mitt

How to Choose the Best Baseball or Fastpitch Softball Catchers Mitt​​​​

This guide will give you everything you need to choose the right catcher's mitt for you or your child.

Catchers Glove vs Catchers Mitt: What Is the Difference?

It may be a small issue, but the terminology is not really the same. Baseball mitts, such as the catchers mitt, keep the fingers closer together, protecting your fingers and providing ball security. Other playing positions use gloves that have separate finger pockets providing more flexibility, versatility, and speed for players.

Choosing the Correct Size Catchers Mitt for Yourself or Your Child

Catchers mitts are measured around the circumference/outer edge of the mitt to include the mitt's entire catching area. They range in size from 29.5" to 34.5" for baseball and 29.5" to 35" for softball. Youth under 13 years old should use a catchers mitt that is 32" or smaller. Youth mitts are easier to close and have narrower fingers.

Adults and youth over 14 years old should use a catchers mitt that is 32" or larger. Using as large a catchers mitt as a player can manage allows for a larger catching area. However, buying a catchers mitt for a child that they will not outgrow too quickly can result in ball control issues.

A quick way to select a catchers mitt size is to measure your or your child's regular baseball glove from the tip of the fingers to the heel of the palm, and subtract that number from 12.5", the largest regular baseball glove size. Take the result and subtract it from 34.5", the largest catchers mitt glove size. This will give you a catchers mitt size to try.

Right (RHT) or Left Handel Thrower (LHT)?

Any baseball glove, even a catchers mitt, should be chosen for the player's non-dominant hand, leaving the player's dominant hand free to perform the all-important task of throwing the ball. That is why mitts and gloves are labeled in relation to which hand a player uses to throw the ball.

So, if you or your child throws the ball with the right hand, then you or your child are right-handed throwers and need a catchers mitt for the left hand. If you or your child throws the ball with the left hand, then you or your child are left-handed throwers and need a catchers mitt for the right hand.

What Is the Best Material for a Catchers Mitt?

Leather is the best choice for catchers mitts for adults. It is durable, comfortable, and stylish. It provides better control and grip. However, leather can be stiff and requires a long break-in period. So, catchers buy a mitt before they need it, so they have up to a couple months to break it in before their old mitt can no longer be used. Some catchers mitts are available with a slight manufacturer-implemented partial factory break-in to lessen the time needed for a player to break in a mitt. Sporting good stores have steamers that can start the break-in process. You can also use oils to help soften the mitt, just do not use too much.

For children, who will outgrow mitts, synthetic, mesh, and pigskin mitts are better choices. While not as durable, they are less expensive and break in quicker.

Should Webbing on a Catchers Mitt be Opened or Closed?

The web or pocket on a catchers mitt is the closed space between the thumb and fingers. This is the most secure area of the glove to catch a ball. The closed web provides more support and better ball control. Catchers mitts also usually have closed backs for wrist support, although open backs provide better mobility. Some catchers mitts also have an external finger slot for the index finger on the back to provide better mobility and control.

What Is the Difference Between a Catchers Mitt for Baseball and Softball?

Because a softball is larger than a baseball, the softball catchers mitt can be bigger with a deeper pocket and thinner sidewalls. However, that can decrease agility and visibility. To counteract this, softball catchers mitts may have open webbing for better visibility. In addition, although catchers mitts probably already have extra padding, softball catcher mitts might have even more padding for protection from the larger ball. There just cannot be too much padding so that ball control is lost. Some softball catchers mitts use a thinner type of padding to solve this issue.

What Kind of Catchers Mitt Do You Need for Fastpitch Softball?

A fast pitch catchers mitt is larger, usually 34", with a deeper pocket and thinner padding on the edges to catch the softball that is larger. To be continuously catching fastballs, fast pitch catchers mitts have to be strong and durable. However, they are harder to break-in. Instead of fingers, fastpitch catchers mitts have upraised rims to direct the ball to the pocket better. Many have a hole for the index finger to help the catcher use the index fingers strength. Having a fastpitçh catchers mitt with an adjustable strap allows the catcher to add a padded glove for more protection.

The Ten Best Catchers Mitts for Sale in 2018!

See each glove review below!

Baseball Catchers Mitts for Adults and Youth Over 14

1. AllStar CM3000SBT 33.5" Catchers Mitt

The AllStar CM3000SBT 33.5" Catchers Mitt is a right-handed throwers mitt, meaning it is intended to be used on the left hand. Made from tanned steer hide, it has been processed for fast break-in and extended life. The extended pro pocket and stiff backing provides support, ball control, and long-lasting durability. The locking tab back and the smooth back design makes the mitt more comfortable, less bulky, and more easily adjustable. It has a reinforced closed web for better protection, support, and ball control.

  • Structure and material make it a long lasting and durable mitt.
  • Easy to break in 
  • Comfortable, lightweight, with good mobility.
  • Good for 75-100 MPH pitching.
  • Relatively expensive if you're note a serious baseball player

2. Wilson A2000 CM33 33" Baseball Catcher's Mitt

The Wilson A2000 CM33 33" Baseball Catcher's Mitt is a right-handed throwers mitt, that means it is for the left hand. It has an extended palm and a half moon web for more catching surface and better ball control. Made from pro-stock leather with Dual Welting for pocket stability, long-lasting form, and durability, it is processed for easier break-in. Your hand stays cool and dry in the mitt due to the Dri-Lex wrist lining. It provides a deeper pocket and catching area for scooping up balls from the ground and better ball control. With a thinner heel pad, it is lighter, breaks in quicker, and allows a quicker transfer to the throwing hand. It has an open back for better mobility.

  • Long lasting and durable material - can last hundreds of games.
  • Comfortable glove with great support and mobility.
  • Lining and ventilation keep hand dry.
  • Deep pocket to make plays at the plate.
  • Takes a little more work to break-in.
  • Oil can discolor it.

3. Mizuno 34" World Win GXC75 Catcher's Mitt

The Mizuno 34" World Win GXC75 Catcher's Mitt is a right-handed throwers mitt meaning it is a left handed catchers mitt. Made of tanned retro (weathered) leather, it is soft, easy to break-in, and immediately ready for in-game use. The ParaShock finger channels provide more protection for the hand. With the Stabilizer System, your hand stays in the right position.

  • Easy to break-in. Ready for game play.
  • Good protection to prevent hand injuries.
  • Very stable glove for 70+ MPH pitching.
  • Inexpensive.
  • Less mobility than other gloves.
  • Not as durable as higher quality mitts.

4. Mizuno Samurai Catchers Baseball Gloves

This Mizuno Samurai Catchers Baseball Mitt is a 33" transitional mitt intended for the youth player that is growing into a larger adult mitt. It has narrow youth finger stalls. This right-handed thrower mitt is intended for the left hand. It offers a ParaShock palm and thumb protection technology that provides comfort, more protection, less rebound, and absorbs shock. Made with full grain, oil-treated leather, it provides easy break-in and is game ready. It has a two-piece closed web and open back for more support, better ball control, and better mobility.

  • Great for teens and adults with smaller hands.
  • Good comfort and thumb guard provides extra protection.
  • Stable glove with good padding for hard throws.
  • Fast break-in period.
  • Being transitional, could be outgrown quickly.

5. Mizuno Franchise GXC90B2 33.5" Adult Catcher's Baseball Mitt

This Mizuno Franchise GXC90B2 33.5" Adult Catcher's Baseball Mitt is a left-handed catchers mitt meaning that it is for the right hand. The pre-oiled tumbled Java Leather is durable and game ready. It offers HiLo Lacing to provide a fully laced web with greater support and flexibility. The Ortholite ParaShock palm pad lessens sting and rebound. The OMZO Lining keeps your hand cool and dry. The PST Back Design with inserts between fingers shapes and stabilizes the pocket.

  • Good for left and right handed throwers.
  • Pre-oiled jumbled Java Leather provides durability and fast break-in.
  • HiLo laced web provides support and flexibility.
  • Stable design to prevent injury.
  • Could use more padding in hand.
  • Not as durable for competitive catchers playing 50+ games and catching 75+ MPH.

Best Youth Catcher's Mitts

6. Rawlings Gamer 32" Youth Pro Taper Glove Series Catcher's Mitt

This Rawlings 32" Gamer Youth Baseball Catchers Mitt is a transitional glove with smaller hand openings and lowered finger stalls. Made with full-grain leather that is 80-percent factory broken in, it provides quick break-in and game readiness. The laces are Tennessee Tanning Rawhide Leather for longer-lasting durability. It offers a one-piece closed web, conventional back, and leather reinforced palm and index finger pad for more support, protection, and ball control.

  • Great transitional mitt for youth baseball players.
  • Soft leather provides a short break-in period.
  • Good support and protection for injury prevention.
  • Being transitional, could be outgrown quickly.

7. Mizuno Prospect GXC105 Youth Baseball Catcher's Mitt

This Mizuno Prospect GXC105 32.5" Transitional Youth Baseball Catchers Mitt is available in both right-handed and left-handed throwers for nine to 12 year olds. It features Power Close hinges that help young players close the glove and learn to catch the ball correctly in the pocket. The V Flex Notch provides help with easy closure. The ParaShock palm pad provides comfort and protection. It has a closed back with adjustable straps.

  • Available in both right and left-handed thrower models.
  • Power Close feature helps young players close mitt.
  • Closed back with adjustable straps.
  • Could use more padding in the palm making it not ideal for fast youth throwers.

Best Fastpitch Softball Catcher's Mitts

8. Mizuno Franchise Fastpitch Series 34" Catcher's Mitt

The Mizuno Franchise Fastpitch Series 34" Catcher's Mitt is designed with smaller hand openings and shorter finger stalls for female players. It is a right-handed throwers mitt. Made from pre-oiled, tumbled Java leather, it is durable and game ready. The Ortholite Parashock Palm Pad provides comfort and support. The Hilo QuickForm lacing provides easy support. It offers PowerLock for easy, secure fit. The V-flex notch helps close the glove easier. With the Double Hinge Heel, it has a wider, centered pocket. This makes it the best fastpitch catchers mitt.

  • Pre-oiled, tumbled Java leather makes it a quick break-in time.
  • Good durability for multiple seasons.
  • Technology to help close the glove easier.
  • Wide pocket to make plays at the plate.
  • None we could find.

9. Easton Core Pro 33" Fastpitch Mitt

The Easton Core Pro 33" Fastpitch Mitt is available in both right-handed and left-handed throwers mitts. Made from Diamond Pro Steerhide, it is 70-percent factory broken in and is game ready. It has rolled leather welting and USA tanned professional rawhide lace for long-lasting durability. It provides a wide and deep pocket that is ideal for softball. This makes it the best softball catchers mitt.

  • Available for right and left-handed throwers.
  • Doesn't take a long time to break in.
  • Large pocket to hold a softball well, and good padding for stability.
  • Less mobility than other gloves.

10. Mizuno Prospect GXS101 32.5" Youth Fastpitch Catcher's Mitt

The Mizuno Prospect GXS101 32.5" Youth Fastpitch Catchers Mitt is available in right-handed and left-handed throwers mitts. With the Power Close and V Flex Notch features, young players can easily close the glove around the ball. The ParaShock palm pad provides comfort and protection. For simple and secure fit, Mizuno provides PowerLock Technology. This glove is an excellent choice for rising stars in fast pitch softball.

  • Both right and left-handed models.
  • Glove closes easily around the ball.
  • Secure and comfortable fit with good mobility.
  • Very easy to break-in.
  • Less durability than other mitts.
  • Less thumb protection than other mitts.

Conclusion: The Clear Winners of the Best Catchers Mitts.

We have chosen a winner for each of our three categories. 

For the best adult baseball catchers mitt, we have chosen the Wilson A2000 CM33 33" Baseball Catcher's Mitt. It offers an extended palm, half moon web, and thinner heel pad for more catching surface, better ball control, and quicker transfer to the throwing hand. The Wilson A2000 provides easier break-in and is made from pro-stock leather with Dual Welting for pocket stability, long-lasting form, and durability. The deeper pocket and catching area helps scoop up balls from the ground and provides better ball control. It also has an open back for better mobility.

For the best youth catchers mitt, we choose the Rawlings 32" Gamer Youth Catchers Mitt. This transitional glove is made with full-grain leather that is 80-percent factory broken in for quick break-in and game readiness. With a one-piece closed web, conventional back, and leather reinforced palm and index finger pad, it provides support, protection, and ball control.

For the best fastpitch softball catchers mitt, we have chosen the Mizuno Franchise Fastpitch Series 34" Catcher's Mitt. The pre-oiled, tumbled Java leather makes it durable and game ready. The Ortholite Parashock Palm Pad and Hilo QuickForm lacing provides comfort and support. It offers easy closure around the ball with the V-flex notch. The Double Hinge Heel provides a wider, centered pocket, and the PowerLock provides an easy, secure fit.