Tag Archives | OF

#11: How valuable is Michael Bourn?

Michael Bourn is a shining example of what I like most in a player in fantasy sports: consistency.

His situation was greatly upgraded last season when he was traded from the lowly Astros to the Atlanta Braves at the trade deadline. However, Bourn’s production (runs, average, stolen bases) remained the same after the trade. In a time where just changing teams makes players forget how to play baseball (i.e. Adam Dunn, Edgar Renteria or Jayson Werth anyone?) it’s reassuring that Bourn didn’t have that problem.

His batting average hovered around .300 after July and his stolen bases and runs were also basically the same. He had 10 three-hit games in four months before the trade and five three-hit games in two months with the Braves. Pencil in Atlanta’s historic late-season swoon and you have to think that he would have had better production if the Braves hadn’t tanked so badly.

Martin PradoDan UgglaBrian McCann and Freddie Freeman would probably help any player in terms of production and protection. I think with a full season in this lineup opposed to the young, inexperienced lineup of Houston, Bourn can improve upon his numbers from 2011 (193 hits, 94 runs, 2 home runs, 50 RBI, .294 average, MLB-best 61 steals.) I think he can easily go for 100+ runs and 200 hits while maintaining the same average, runs and steals totals.

When it comes to draft position, he’s definitely a top-100 pick or a top-20 outfielder. He’s more valuable than one might think, and another thing I like is that he’s a proven commodity.

Of all the steal-heavy outfielders (Brett GardnerCoco CrispIchiro SuzukiJuan PierreAngel Pagan and Austin Jackson), Bourn is the best. Of course, like everyone on this list, Bourn’s upside is limited because he possesses almost no power.

If you draft Bourn, getting a power-heavy outfielder isn’t a bad idea as they would compliment each other perfectly. Mike Stanton is the first that comes to mind, but also Nelson Cruz or Jay Bruce.

Whatever the case, you can do much worse than getting Bourn as one of your core four outfielders. He will get you the runs, hits (if they score hits) and stolen bases for you and he has a chance in 2012 to best his 2011 numbers with the Braves and Astros. Go fishing, but not before pick 70.

Read full story · Comments { 1 }

Player Profile #83: Jayson Werth | OF | WAS

Do you think Jayson Werth misses Philadelphia? Maybe he doesn’t, but his fantasy owners surely do. After two straight top-25 season in terms of PSR, Werth put up a big stinker in 2011 ranking 173rd. He was still pretty solid with 20 homers and 19 steals, but his 69 runs, 58 RBI and .232 batting average were anemic to say the least. He’s 32, going on 33, so a decline is expected, but it could also explain his highest ground ball rate (43.0%) and lowest ISO (.157) in four years. One would hope he can at least get close to the level of production we saw with the Phillies, but after a season like he had, it’s hard to act on that faith early in drafts.

Best case scenario: Alex Gordon (KC)
Similar players: Nick Swisher (NYY), Chris Young (ARI), Corey Hart (MIL)
Worst case scenario: Michael Cuddyer (COL)

Strengths

Walks, power/speed. The good news is that even in a down year Werth managed to draw walks 11.4 percent of the time. He was also one steal away from his third 20/20 season and while we’d like him not to have exactly 20 homers and 20 steals, it’s still not a bad accomplishment.

Weaknesses

Batting average, lineup, age. Werth’s .296 batting average in 2010 was a fluke thanks to a .352 BABIP (.307 xBABIP) so don’t expect him to come close to that mark again. It also concerns me how much his run and RBI totals fell with his switch to the Nationals and while I think they are getting better as a team, the top of the order could still use some work.

ADP Report (99.8)

Fantasy owners are ready to give up it seems as his ADP has plummeted after one down season. I think Werth has a shot at another .260/25/80 season with his usual 15-20 steals. That’s not what he was in Philadelphia, but it’s still a top 100 player.

Read full story · Comments { 0 }

Player Profile #86: Jason Heyward | OF | ATL

In 2010, Jason Heyward turned heads with a very solid season as a 20-year-old rookie. His PSR was even in the top 100, so many thought we were looking at the next big thing in fantasy baseball. Well, a combination of injuries and regression hurt his 2011 value, and he ended up ranking a very poor 376th. The good news is that Heyward is still only 21 years old and has plenty of time to develop into a big-time, MLB hitter. The bad news? He has battled injuries for two seasons now and we can’t help but draw cross-sport comparisons with Greg Oden. Let’s hope that’s not the case.

Best case scenario: Justin Upton (ARI)
Similar players: Michael Cuddyer (COL), Nick Swisher (NYY), Corey Hart (MIL)
Worst case scenario: Shoulder injury comes back

Strengths

Plate discipline, power, age. His plate discipline took a step backwards last season, but he still has an above average career O-Swing% (26.1%) and OBP (.362), especially for someone his age. Also, his raw power is drool-inducing when you consider that he has 32 home runs in 916 at-bats (28.63 AB/HR) with a career 54.6 ground ball percentage.

Weaknesses

Ground balls, injuries. If Heyward can figure out how to hit more fly balls (career 29.7%) his home run totals would sky rocket. Unfortunately there have been no signs of that getting better so it’s just blind faith that he will keep improving as a hitter. It also doesn’t help that he spent almost the entire 2011 season nursing a shoulder injury.

ADP Report (108.3)

We at Baseball Professor are definitely buying into the potential that Heyward has, and I think he’s worth a gamble as early as the seventh round. I’ll admit that expectations for 2012 should be tempered, but in keeper leagues he shouldn’t be lasting past the fifth round because the potential is there for him to be a top-10 outfielder for the next 10 years.

Read full story · Comments { 0 }

Player Profile #89: Corey Hart | OF | MIL

We’ve used Corey Hart rather frequently as out best-case scenario for outfielders with good pop, a solid average and enough speed to have some impact in steals. Despite playing in just 130 games last season, Hart managed to rank 91st by season’s end, but how will the loss of Prince Fielder affect Hart’s 2012 stat line? That’s hard to know seeing as Hart bounced all around the Milwaukee lineup last season, settling in as the team’s leadoff hitter when Rickie Weeks‘ season ended prematurely, but I’ll go out on a limb here and guess Fielder’s absence won’t be beneficial. Hart still has 30-homer power and will continue to post averages around .280, but Milwaukee’s overall run production will suffer greatly. Oh, and some guy named Ryan Braun will miss some time, too.

Best case scenario: Josh Hamilton (TEX) assuming Hamilton misses about 30 games, which he usually does
Similar players: Nelson Cruz (TEX), Adam Jones (BAL), Carlos Santana (CLE)
Worst case scenario: Josh Willingham (MIN)

Strengths

HR, R, balance. If you thought Hart was destined to become a balanced 20/20 threat a few years back, join the club. Instead, he traded in the speed for power and now he’s a 30-homer threat. We’ll see where he bats in Milwaukee’s lineup (MLBDepthCharts.com has him slated at fifth right now with Braun factored in) but he could see a lot of time hitting ahead of Braun and new third baseman Aramis Ramirez. If that’s the case, Hart will be a good source of runs. Either way, he does a little bit of everything.

Weaknesses

Milwaukee’s deteriorating lineup, hitting on the road. With Fielder gone and Braun (for now) out of the lineup, Hart won’t be getting the same support he’s used to in Milwaukee. Hart’s also batted just .256 with 27 homers in 195 games on the road over the last three seasons versus .301 with 45 homers in 195 games at home over the same span.

ADP Report (89.8)

It seems mock drafters value Hart just like we do. He ranked 91 last year despite missing time due to injury, and even though he should play more games this season, the significant lineup changes in Milwaukee will likely counter any positive effect those extra games will have on Hart’s end-of-season stat line.

Read full story · Comments { 0 }

Player Profile #98: Ichiro Suzuki | OF | SEA

Have we seen the end of Ichiro Suzuki as a productive fantasy outfielder? I’m going to say no, but we are definitely getting close. Ichiro hit under .300 for the first time in his career (.272) and posted his worst ISO (.064) in 2011. He’s also gone three straight years with fewer than 90 runs scored. That being said, he still stole 40 bases last year, his .295 BABIP was much lower than his career rate (.351) and his xBA (.293) was not the usual .310-plus but undoubtedly better than the .272 we saw. I think Ichiro can get back to hitting .300 with close to 40 steals for at least one more season, but the Mariners offense is so bad these days that 90 runs is unfortunately the best case for him.

Best case scenario: Michael Bourn (ATL) with fewer runs
Similar players: Cameron Maybin (SD), Emilio Bonifacio (MIA), Coco Crisp (OAK)
Worst case scenario: Juan Pierre (PHI)

Strengths

Steals, batting average. Even at 37, Ichiro posted back-to-back 40-steal seasons with an 83.7 percent success rate. As for his batting average, I don’t see him posting a sub-.300 BABIP again so he should be back around .300.

Weaknesses

Age, power. Ichiro’s endurance over his career has been pretty amazing. He’s played in at least 161 games in seven of his last eight seasons, but you have to think age will catch up with him eventually.

ADP Report (104.9)

Even though Ichiro is on the downside of his career, he’s a pretty good value in the 11th round. Before, when Ichiro was being drafted as an OF1 he had to hit .330 to bring back equal value, but with his current ADP he only needs to hit around .300 to keep his owners happy. I think for the first time in his career we can say Ichiro is being underrated in drafts.

Read full story · Comments { 0 }

Player Profile #103: Cameron Maybin | OF | SD

Cameron Maybin is in the class of players with significant deficiencies who do one thing well enough to rank rather well. In Maybin’s case, it’s the steals. There are some concerns surrounding his ability to replicate his 40 steals, namely that his previous career-best at any level was 30 in his 2008 season split between the majors and minors. Maybin can score runs and has a little pop, but San Diego’s ballpark and lineup will suppress both of those. Cross your fingers for Maybin owners that 2012 goes something like 2011.

Best case scenario: B.J. Upton (TB) but with a little less pop
Similar players: Emilio Bonifacio (MIA), Angel Pagan (SF), Ichiro Suzuki (SEA) with a .250 average
Worst case scenario: Loses his starting job and is reduced to being a pinch runner

Strengths

Speed, vs. LHP. The speed we’ve already covered. Maybin doesn’t have a ton of major league experience, but he did bat .296 versus left-handed pitchers last season.

Weaknesses

RBI, park/lineup, reliability. The park and lineup have already been recounted so I won’t cover that again. Maybin did tally just 40 RBI last season, but he did that batting all over the San Diego lineup. This season he’s currently slated to bat third. Will that continue, and, even if it does, can Maybin actually be a good bat for the middle of the Padres’ order?

ADP Report (101.5)

Maybin ranked 82nd last season and should drive in more runs by virtue of his lineup slot, but you should know there’s an inherent amount of risk selecting Maybin anywhere in the 90-110 range. There are safer options available, but if he gets regular playing time (which he should, barring injury) and he still runs like last season, this is where he’ll likely end up ranking.

Read full story · Comments { 0 }

Player Profile #105: Chris Young | OF | ARI

Color me biased (I’ve owned Chris Young for the last two seasons and I’m keeping him this season) but I think the Arizona outfielder is one of the more undervalued assets in fantasy. No one likes taking on a player with a career .240 average, but he’s had back-to-back 20/20 seasons and will almost certainly be in line for a third. At this point in his career, we know who Young is, and if it weren’t for the other contributors on this site who don’t value Young as highly as I do (damn you, George!), Young would definitely be a top-100 player.

Best case scenario: B.J. Upton (TB)
Similar players: Drew Stubbs (CIN), Jeff Francoeur (KC), Andrew McCutchen (PIT) with a lower BA
Worst case scenario: Ryan Roberts (ARI)

Strengths

Power, speed, run/RBI combo. Young has been a 20/20 player in each of the last two seasons and added in a third 20/20 year back in 2007. For his career, he averages 23 homers and 21 steals per 156 games (the exact amount he’s played the last two seasons). Young tends to bounce around the Arizona lineup, but in general he’s their fifth hitter. Batting behind Justin Upton and Miguel Montero, two very good bats, should equal plenty of RBI despite the low average, and his speed is enough to help him elevate his run total…again, despite the low average.

Weaknesses

Batting average. Young will be lucky to bat .257 again, and something right around .240 is what we should expect. If he was even able to bat .270 he’d be a top 25-50 option, but that’s a pipe dream.

ADP Report (125.0)

People really hate Young. Because of his low average, everyone seems to assume he’s more of a detriment to your team than he really is, but having a player like Young allows you to take on other undervalued players like Michael Young who can give you a great batting average but don’t help you much in homers or steals. Last season Michael Young finished 46th and Chris Young finished 99th, but because of their perceived shortcomings their ADPs this season are 71 and 125, respectively. Pairing them would produce incredible combined value and be a shrewd move.

Read full story · Comments { 1 }
  • 2012 Fantasy Baseball Rankings
  • About BaseballProf
  • Top 100 Offseason Questions
  • Contact
  • 2011 Draft Preview
  • 2012 Fantasy Preview
  • Daily SP Matchup Ratings
  • Draft Strategies
  • Player Movement
  • Podcast
  • Professor's Blog
  • Top 100 Offseason Questions
  • Top 200 Fantasy Rankings
  • 2012
  • 2011
  • 2010
  • 2009