True to our site’s name, we’ve been doing a lot of stat-heavy, intensive articles here at Baseball Professor. They aren’t crazy in-depth studies like you’ll find on other sites because we do our best to keep them around 1,000 words and manageable for people of all levels of baseball knowledge, but they aren’t 20 minute fluff pieces either.
That’s what this article is!
To break up the long prose and sometimes convoluted stats, I thought I’d sit down and write a bunch of thoughts I have about the state of starting pitching in 2012. I’ll avoid just asking questions since we’ve already gone and listed a bunch of those in our Top 100 Offseason Questions series, so my hope is that this article inspires a little discussion in the comments section. To our frequent commenters (yeah, there’s a few of you) we thank you for reading our articles and contributing your thoughts. To our hundreds of loyal readers who don’t comment frequently, what are you waiting for?! Anyway, here are some of my early offseason thoughts on starting pitching for your (hopeful) commenting pleasure:
- It came across the news wire yesterday that Melky Cabrera has been shipped to San Francisco in exchange for Jonathan Sanchez. If you read yesterday’s other article regarding Alex Gordon‘s value next season, you already know I downgraded his run and RBI potential because it’s likely that Cabrera was going to regress. Now, with his bat completely removed from the lineup, we have to wonder where all that extra production is going to come from. As for Sanchez, he finished with the 48th best home run rate last season out of 145 pitchers that threw at least 100 innings and he’s actually moving from a park that discourages home runs to one that downright punishes home run hitters. The average non-San Fran NL West offense last season ranked 16.5 in the league in runs scored whereas the average non-KC AL Central offense ranked 15.8th. There’s not a ton of difference here. If anything I sort of like the move since the Royals have a better chance at a stronger offense as of today.
- Do you know Yu Darvish? Over the last five years in Japan he’s compiled a 75-28 record and a sub-2.00 ERA. Many believe he’d be the ace of many current MLB rotations. It’s not decided if/where he’ll pitch, but if he does become available it’s going to be something to keep an eye on.
- With the Rays picking up James Shields‘ extension, it looks unlikely that they’ll trade their ace. Who are some names to watch for offseason movement? Gio Gonzalez, Wandy Rodriguez, John Danks, Gavin Floyd, Ricky Nolasco, Jeremy Guthrie and some less important names have been rumored to be available. Of those names I think Gonzalez has the most to lose from a fantasy perspective. In the unlikely event he’s traded, he’ll likely go to a contender with a better offense, but I’d hate to have him leave that ballpark.
- I’m bullish on Jon Lester in 2012. Maybe it’s the Red Sox fan in me, but Lester was the only member of the team’s rotation to come forward and really acknowledge their lack of effort, and with his semi-contrite half-confession (at this point I’ll take what I can get) and the team’s new management, I can’t help but think it’s all systems go heading forward. I’m willing to gamble on Lester being a low-tier ace (read: top 10 SP) next season.
- Speaking of the Red Sox, it’s no surprise that they were again among the league’s most potent offenses, but with John Lackey and Daisuke Matsuzaka victims of Tommy John, two-fifths of the Boston rotation is currently vacant. The Yankees are having issues of their own, so is it any surprise that the Red Sox and Yankees are bumbling big money teams while the Rays, and their dearth of young pitching, continue to threaten for the division and the Rangers have made back-to-back World Series appearances, this time on the back of a top-10 starting rotation? Enough with the ranting. From a fantasy perspective, whoever wins those rotation spots in Boston and New York are likely to stumble into a few wins, but don’t let that change how you value them as fantasy contributors. Somehow Lackey ended up with 12 wins and a .500 record, besting Doug Fister‘s 11-13 mark (but not his 2.83 ERA). Wins suck.
- The more I look at Brandon Beachy‘s stats, the more impressed I am with him as a pitcher. He had a 3.19 FIP, the eighth best O-Contact% (percent of pitches outside the strike zone that batters swing and miss at) of the 145 pitchers who threw at least 100 innings and the 16th best strikeout-to-walk ratio. Expect big things from this kid.
- Justin Verlander finished with a .236 BABIP against, the fourth lowest rate of said 145 pitchers. We know this rate fluctuates wildly for pitchers from year to year, so how much regression should Verlander see? His previous career low was .279. If the relationship between his FIP, xFIP and ERA tells us anything, it says we should expect an ERA over 3.00 next year. Either way, that will certainly be elite.
- I don’t understand Matt Cain. 2011 was the first time I had ever conceded that Cain was as good as his inexplicable peripherals indicate and then he replicated them again. His .260 BABIP is now the norm and not an outlier (career .265) and his while his career 4.26 xFIP depicts a pitcher better suited to be a team’s number three, Cain is every bit the ace that Tim Lincecum is. Between Cain, Lincy and Madison Bumgarner, it’s no wonder why the Giants felt they could let Sanchez go.
- Who’s the real Justin Masterson? Is it the guy who can’t get lefties out and masquerades as a legitimate part of a major league rotation or the guy who shuts down elite offenses and masquerades as the ace of a rebuilding team’s rotation? I have no friggen clue…yet.
- I do not believe in Josh Collmenter so don’t even think about drafting him next year. He allows too many fly balls (47%) for the park he plays in and his BABIP (.255) is too low.
- Even though I badmouthed him all season, it might be time to buy Vance Worley. His end-of-season BABIP (.283) isn’t awfully low and his FIP (3.32) is actually very good. He’s always had great control in the minors, but I do wonder if he’ll replicate that 8.13 K/9 from last season. My thought is no.
- I feel bad for anyone in a keeper league who needs to decide what to do with Ubaldo Jimenez. I wouldn’t wish that kind of mental torture on anyone. He has so much potential but we haven’t seen him pitch well since early 2010. That’s like nine months of baseball without a stretch that gives you any semblance of confidence. Seriously, how do you evaluate this guy? Do you take the chance that he’s the Jimenez of old and hold onto him or do you cut your losses and play it safe with someone like Aramis Ramirez? Maybe you roll the dice and go with the uber-talented Colby Rasmus. I do think Toronto is a good situation for him. By the way, I’ve been describing my offseason dilemma this whole time. Tell me what to do!
