I had plenty of time to write this post last night while watching the Red Sox finally beat someone they’re supposed to, but the 18 runs they scored conveniently masked the fact that John Lackey once again turned in another terrible outing. Given how much Boston needed that game, he just can’t allow three runs in the first inning. Has any pitcher gone from near-ace to possibly the worst starter in the league as quickly as Lackey has? I wanted to say he was pulling a Zito, but Lackey’s ineptitude reaches lows I’m not sure even Zito knows. The fact that Lackey has 12 wins on the year is an insult to pitchers everywhere and is further proof of the idiocy of anyone who believes Felix Hernandez‘s 13 wins last year weren’t good enough to win the Cy Young. You want to tell me that Lackey of ’11 and Hernandez of ’10 have been nearly as good because they’re separated by just one win? I bet you also thought disco was here to stay or the internet was just a fad.
Since many leagues make you add your starters a day in advance, here are my thoughts on the pitching matchups for tomorrow, Wednesday, September 21.
Good Matchups
- Vance Worley, PHI (vs. WAS) – If I’ve said it once, I shouldn’t have to say it again. Start Worley at home (6-0, 2.01 ERA) and at night (9-0, 1.61 ERA). A home, night game versus Washington? Can he allow negative earned runs?
- James Shields, TB (@NYY) — Shields is ranked 17th on the season and has reached “start him against any opponent” status, but it’s worth noting that he has absolutely dominated the Yankees in three starts this season. His 1-2 record versus the Bombers doesn’t do his 1.59 ERA and 1.01 WHIP any justice (22 2/3 innings), and his opponent, Phil Hughes, hasn’t pitched well against a good offense since August 13 (a 9-2 win against Tampa Bay).
- C.J. Wilson, TEX (@OAK) — Wilson has almost reached “start him against anyone” status, but even though he’s not quite there yet he has attainated “could turn in a gem on any given day” status, especially when facing an Oakland team that he’s posted a 3.09 ERA and 1.14 WHIP against this season (35 IP). His road numbers this year (2.31 ERA, 1.12 WHIP, .218 OBA) give me even more confidence.
- Michael Pineda, SEA (@ MIN) — The Twinkies are the perfect remedy for the struggling Pineda who hasn’t collected a win since beating Tampa Bay on July 30. That doesn’t mean the Mariners’ phenom has pitched poorly, though. In the six starts since that last W he has five quality starts and has rebounded quite nicely from a disastrous July and early-August. Minnesota is 2-14 this month and has scored just 55 runs in 16 games (3.45 runs per game). The one silver lining (for Minnesota, not Pineda) is that the Twins don’t strike out much at all.
- Wade Miley, ARI (vs. PIT) — The Pirates aren’t exactly an offensive juggernaut, but they’re exceptionally bad against LHP (.657 OPS, league average .722). Miley has been rather impressive as a starter this year, but he tends to walk a lot of batters. This isn’t a case-closed, great-outing-in-the-making for Miley, but he’s one of your better, low-quality options.
- Matt Garza, CHC (vs. MIL) – Garza has allowed more than three earned runs in just seven of his 29 starts this season, but two of them are against Milwaukee. Garza is great at home and Milwaukee has been scuffling offensively in September (23rd in runs scored), so I’m rolling the dice here.
- Ubaldo Jimenez, CLE (vs. CHW) — Look who’s strung together five straight quality starts! Jimenez’s walk rate is very high and his ERA versus the White Sox is just 4.08 this year, but his opponent, Mark Buehrle, has been incredibly bad of late. That could mean a win.
- Javier Vazquez, FLA (vs. ATL) — Vazquez is a monster! His ERA has gone down every single month and his ERA/WHIP combo sits at 2.35 and 0.93, respectively, in 80 1/3 innings after the All-Star Break. He’s allowed just one earned run in his last four starts (0.31 ERA in 29 innings), but amazingly none of his 30 starts this season have come against division opponent Atlanta.
- Bronson Arroyo, CIN (vs. HOU) — We joke about how bad Houston’s offense is and like they say, most jokes are rooted in truth. In this case there’s a lot of truth. Houston’s offense ranks last in the league in runs in September. If you can’t start Arroyo against the Astros, who can you start him against?
- Randy Wolf, MIL (@CHC) — By almost any measure, the Cubs have a middle-of-the-road offense, even when they’re at home. Wolf has made three starts against the Cubbies this season and has compiled a nicely polished 1.37 ERA in the process. To give you even more confidence, September has been his best month of the season so far.
- Jaime Garcia, STL (vs. NYM) — Garcia put an end to another second-half slide with three nice starts in a row in September. The Mets 7-5 win on Sunday put an end to a streak of six straight games scoring two or fewer runs. Clearly they aren’t hitting, so now is the time to strike!
- Ryan Vogelsong, SF (@LAD) — Sometimes life ain’t fair. From August 19 to September 10, Vogelsong went 0-5 over five starts despite a sterling 3.37 ERA during that span. You see, the problem with San Franciso starters is they force you to gamble that the San Francisco offense will score enough runs to get them a win. Over those five starts the Giants scored a whopping four runs…total. Not four runs per game. Four runs total. As for Vogelsong’s matchup in particular, he’s allowed just three earned runs in 14 2/3 innings against the Dodgers this season (1.84 ERA).
- Dana Eveland, LAD (vs. SF) — Speaking of the Giants, guess who’s facing them. Eveland shut down San Fran on September 10, allowing just three hits and zero runs over seven innings. It’s odd to see me recommend two starters from one game, but low-scoring affairs between the Giants and Dodgers are all the rage these days. In only six of the 15 games between these teams this season has one team scored more than five runs and two of those games were way back in the year’s opening series.
Bad Matchups
- Wandy Rodriguez, HOU (@CIN) — His May and June were pretty much off the chart (by the way, where is this oft-referenced chart?), but he’s been a 4.00-ish ERA guy for the rest of the season. Still, an 11-10 record pitching for a 53-100 team is pretty impressive, but this isn’t a great matchup for Rodriguez. He has an ERA of 6.00 in two starts against a Reds team that has the league’s third-best OPS versus LHP this season. Complicating matters, his 1.52 WHIP during day games is ninth worst of 112 pitchers who have tossed at least 40 innings under the sun.
- Brandon McCarthy, OAK (vs. TEX) — McCarthy has been great at home (2.77 ERA) and in the second half (3.18 ERA), but Texas has pounded him this year (5.06 ERA in 21 2/3 IP).
- Max Scherzer, DET (@KC) — Scherzer has faced the Royals four times this season, allowing two earned runs in 12 2/3 innings in his first two starts and 11 earned runs in just eight innings in his last two starts. This downward trend against the Royals offense was punctuated by a 9-5 KO by KC on August 29. In that game Scherzer allowed homers to backup catcher Sam Perez and light-hitting shortstop Alcides Escobar. Now almost a month later, neither player has homered since and they’ve combined for four home runs in 641 at-bats this year. You call it bad luck. I call it bad skill.
- Phil Hughes, NYY (vs. TB) — Hughes’ walk rate ranks 114th of 182 pitchers who have thrown at least 70 innings, a rate which puts him right near the bottom third of the league. Tampa Bay’s 74 walks in September are first in the league and, for whatever reason, Hughes has a 7.83 ERA and .326 OBA at Yankee Stadium.
- Anthony Bass, SD (@COL) — Never send a relief pitcher to do a starting pitcher’s job…until that relief pitcher has turned in several solid performances as a starter. Then start him at will. Sadly, though, that doesn’t describe Bass.
- Kevin Slowey, MIN (vs. SEA) — It takes some skill, or lack thereof, for me to recommend you don’t start someone against the Mariners, but Slowey has been awful all year and his team can’t win games.
- Mark Buehrle, CHW (@CLE) — Cleveland is just 7-11 this month, but that’s more a reflection of a pitching staff that has allowed the second most runs in the league since September 1 and less of their offense that ranks 10th over that span. Buehrle has pitched well at home this year (2.85 ERA) but he’s allowed at least six earned runs in each of his last three starts and hasn’t fared well versus the Indians (7.11 ERA in 19 IP).
- Jeremy Hellickson, TB (@NYY) — Last week I called Hellickson’s start against the Red Sox a bad matchup because of his walk rate on the road and how lucky I feel he’s been this year, and then he goes and lets up just three hits and one earned run over 5 2/3 innings. Despite the fact that he was one out away from his sixth straight quality start, I’ll once again project a bad outing from the Rays’ rookie. He was roughed up for four earned runs in 4 1/3 innings at New York on August 13, and this start will be similar.
- Tommy Hunter, BAL (@BOS) — The Red Sox are just 3-5 over their last eight games, a stretch that’s been bookended by two 18-run offensive outbursts. In the six games in between, the team has averaged just 3.83 runs per game. We’ll probably know by the end of the second inning whether Hunter’s going to polish off a gem, but with the way he’s been pitching over the last two months (5.31 ERA in 57 2/3 IP) that’s an unlikely outcome.
- Chris Schwinden, NYM (@ STL) — Relievers usually don’t last long enough to pick up the win, so you only want to start them when their K potential is high and they’re facing a bad offense. St. Louis isn’t hitting particularly well of late, but they’re talented enough for me to pass here.





