We are just 10 days away from the trade deadline and I can already feel the ground trembling from the nerves of fantasy owners across the world. Rumors o’ plenty have been swirling around for weeks now—some that I believe (Colby Rasmus leaving St. Louis) and some that I don’t (the Red Sox heavily pursuing Carlos Beltran). Still, players can gain or lose a lot of value based on rumors so it’s best to capitalize while you can.
It’s always hard to sort out through all of the trade talk, but maybe I can give you a little comfort in what otherwise will be a hectic week and a half. Let’s start with the most obvious potential move of 2011:
Carlos Beltran leaves New York, Jose Reyes doesn’t
Result: Lucas Duda starts regularly for the rest of the season
Why it happens: This is pretty much a given, right? It makes too much sense for the Mets not to trade away Carlos Beltran, who will be a free agent after this year. The Mets can’t offer him arbitration thanks to a clause in his contract so should they lose him in free agency, they will not get any compensation. They need to cash in on this amazing comeback season.
The Mets have already said that they won’t trade Jose Reyes so I guess we’ll believe them.
Fantasy outlook: Well, for one he will be leaving Citi Field (plus) and possibly the NL East (double-plus). He currently plays in a division with Roy Halladay, Cole Hamels, Cliff Lee, Tommy Hanson, Jair Jurrjens, Josh Johnson, Anibal Sanchez and Jordan Zimmermann. He will not shed a tear.
As for Lucas Duda, he is currently playing full-time at first base, but when David Wright returns he will be moved to the outfield full-time. He can provide some sneaky power in deeper leagues, but I wouldn’t worry about him in shallow leagues.
Heath Bell won’t get traded
Result: Nothing changes
Why it doesn’t happen: The trade market is littered with relief pitchers and I find it hard to believe that any team will pay the steep price to acquire Heath Bell‘s services. The Padres will get two first round picks if they let him walk so they need an offer that includes two very good prospects.
Bell has been linked to teams like the Phillies, Yankees, Rays, Blue Jays and the Cardinals, but why wouldn’t those teams pay a lesser price for Mike Adams, Koji Uehara or Kyle Farnsworth (not the Rays obviously) instead?
Fantasy outlook: There’s really nothing to react to in this situation. Even if Bell were to be traded, there is no way he goes to a team where he isn’t the full-time closer because no team would pay that steep of a price for a set up man. Except the Yankees. If he does end up leaving the Padres, the obvious fill ins would be Adams (if he’s still there) and then Chad Qualls or Luke Gregerson.
B.J. Upton and James Shields will be traded
Result: Desmond Jennings finally gets called up and maybe we see a Matt Moore sighting
Why it happens: The Rays are in a very unique situation. They have been competitive for four years now, but they still don’t draw much attention in their home town. What this does is allow them to make bold moves because they don’t have to worry about any backlash from public perception. What, are they going to get even fewer fans?
Trading James Shields makes sense because his value is at the highest point it will ever be and even though he has friendly team-options for the next three years ($28 million total) he’s not irreplaceable. The Rays have plenty of young arms ready to contribute.
As for B.J. Upton, the truth is that he’s better in fantasy than he is in reality. His .318 OBP is embarrasing and the Rays could easily replace that with Jennings.
Fantasy outlook: Shields has been linked to the Reds and Tigers in potential deals. Even though he would be leaving the pitcher-friendly Trop, leaving the AL East will counter any negative park factors.
With Upton, a change of scenery can only be a good thing. Maybe he gets motivated for two months and goes on a tear? Either way, while the counting numbers are there, Upton could help a lot by upping that batting average a bit and start getting on base more.
With the new roster space the Rays will be forced to call up Desmond Jennings ending one of the more frustrating two months of my life fantasy owners’ lives. At 24, he may no longer be considered a prospect, but he can steals bases in bunches in the majors and has a little bit of power to go along with it. Matt Moore dazzled scouts in his one inning of work at the Future’s game during the All-Star break and the prospect could be called upon if the Rays don’t slip at all in the standings. He would be worth a flier in all leagues and is a must-own even now in dynasty or keeper leagues.
Ubaldo Jimenez will not be traded
Result: Business as usual
Why it doesn’t happen: Can we stop with these ridiculous rumors already? The Rockies just invested $237.75 million in Troy Tulowitzki and Carlos Gonzalez and they are going to trade away their best pitcher in Ubaldo Jimenez, who is owed $4.2 million next season and then a total of $13.75 million in team options in 2013-14? C’mon now.
Fantasy outlook: Jimenez has turned his season around and you should continue to treat him as a top 20 starting pitcher in fantasy.
Colby Rasmus should get traded, but will he?
Result: Undetermined
Why it should happen: The Cardinals have the deal right there, they just need to pull the trigger. Colby Rasmus for Upton and a pitcher. Cardinals get that extra push for 2011, while the Rays replace the soon-to-be-expensive Upton for the cheap Rasmus.
Why it won’t happen: Screw it, he has to get traded. It makes too much sense! It’s a well-known fact that he asked to be traded last year, which ruffled some feathers in the clubhouse. LaRussa has also had his problems with the young outfielder so why would they keep him around?
Fantasy outlook: It’s clear that Rasmus has the talents to be a great contributor in fantasy. When he’s in his right mind, he gets on base regularly with walks, can swipe his fair share of bases and also has 25-homer potential. It’s undetermined whether Rasmus absolutely wants out of St. Louis, but the signs are there and he may never reach his full potential in a Cardinals uniform.