This past Monday I represented the Baseball Professors in an experts draft hosted by Dave Gawron over at RotoExperts.com. It was my first time in an AL-Only auction, but I was very interested in how it would play out and share my experience with you. Hopefully it will help you, the reader, in any leagues similar to this format.
Let’s first get into my strategy going into the draft.
AL-only auction strategy
I thought about going off results from other well-known AL-only auction leagues in the “expert” fantasy baseball community, but then I remembered the golden rule of auctions: every draft is it’s own beast. So here were my main objectives in the draft.
-
Don’t spend big on catchers.
-
Spend $30 on two players with minimal batting average risk.
-
Spend $20 on an elite closer.
-
Don’t spend over $18 on any pitcher.
-
Get Carl Crawford if he’s under $25.
-
Don’t spend too much money early so I can have leverage late in the draft.
Knowing these goals, let’s see how disciplined I was during the draft to meet them. My 2012 Triple Crown AL-Only roster:
(You can find everyone’s roster in a google doc here. Just make sure you click on the AL-Only tab on the bottom. Let me know what you think of my team or share your own deep league draft experience in the comments section below!)
Catchers
Jarrod Saltalamacchia ($10), Yorvit Torrealba ($3), J.R. Towles (R)
I really like Saltalamacchia at $10 because he really came on strong in the second half last season and could have sneaky, 20-homer power. I thought getting him for $10 when the top tier was going for around $21.
Torrealba was one of the final catchers that was guaranteed consistent playing time so while I went above my $1 budget for my second catcher it was well worth it.
Towles in the reserve round was in all honesty a mistake pick and will probably be dropped on my first waiver move.
First Basemen
Mark Teixeira ($32), Chris Parmelee ($1), Matt LaPorta ($1)
I broke my rule about spending $30 on players with little batting average risk with Mark Teixeira. First base is very top heavy in the AL as there is a pretty steep dropoff after Eric Hosmer and I didn’t want to pay a premium price for him ($30). In addition, guys like Prince Fielder ($35) and Adrian Gonzalez ($36) were going for a bit much in my opinion. I think Tex at $32 is a good middle ground.
I have to say, after a very nice September Chris Parmelee intrigues me a bit. His .355 batting average was inflated by a .390 BABIP, but that doesn’t mean he can’t hit a respectable .280. Unfortunately, he doesn’t have much power to speak of. We know the injury risk that comes with Justin Morneau so Parmelee should have plenty of opportunities to prove himself at the plate.
Matt LaPorta, at this point, is what he is and that’s a Quad-A player who we can hope will someday bust out and reward all his fantasy owners who took that chance (fingers crossed!).
Second Basemen
Dustin Pedroia ($33), Maicer Izturis ($2), Ben Zobrist ($27) <– will use at OF
Dustin Pedroia was probably my top target going into this draft for two reasons: (1) He’s very safe in terms of injury/batting average and (2) he’s as close to a five-category stud as there is in the American League. He’s well worth the money.
Maicer Izturis is nothing special, that’s for sure, but as a middle infielder in an AL-only league he was worth the extra buck. However, with the logjam of hitters that the Angels currently have, he might be hard pressed to find consistent playing time. The Angels really need to make a move…or three.
Third Basemen
Mike Moustakas ($18), Maicer Izturis ($2)
Mike Moustakas was my first immediate regret, you know that feeling after you hit the bid button and immediately hope the guy you were bidding with goes one more dollar. At the time in the draft I had limited funds and no third baseman with Moustakas, Edwin Encarnacion, Eduardo Nunez and Danny Valencia were available. I spent the extra money to secure Moose Tacos because of his upside and so he better pay off. Then again, Nunez went for $16 so maybe I didn’t spend as much as I thought.
Shortstops
Elvis Andrus ($25)
Elvis Andrus the best shortstop in the American League so he’s worth paying top dollar for. I’m in the camp that Andrus has some untapped power potential and we could see him get into this year. He’s a line drive machine so he just needs to get a little under the ball and we might be able to pair 10 home runs with those 35-40 steals.
Outfielders
Ben Zobrist ($27), Carl Crawford ($22), Denard Span ($7), Shelley Duncan ($1), Hideki Matsui ($1), Mitch Maier (R)
There’s not much to say about Ben Zobrist and Carl Crawford. With Zobrist you are getting a 20/20 player with plenty of runs and RBI. In Crawford’s case, if he can come back healthy and produce like a top-10 OF from May to October he will give $30+ production. Of course there’s a lot of risk there as well so there’s a reason he comes at a bargain price.
Denard Span might be a forgotten man by most this season, but if you need a cheap source of steals and runs he’s your guy. Shelley Duncan may not have a full-time job, but the Indians are reluctant to start him in the OF on a daily basis. With Sizemore being his usual injured self, Duncan should see increased playing time.
Starting Pitchers
Max Scherzer ($17), Justin Masterson ($15), Doug Fister ($12), Tom Milone ($6), Scott Baker ($5), Kevin Slowey ($2), Jason Hammel ($1), Phil Humber (R), Andrew Miller (R)
This unit could make or break my season because I didn’t spend on any big-time arms. I feel confident in my three “big money” buys (Max Scherzer, Justin Masterson, Doug Fister) as they should all provide solid strikeout totals (I’m starting to come around a little on Fister as a mid-to-high 5 K/9 guy).
Tom Milone has looked good this spring (9 K:1 BB in 12 2/3 innings), but he’s given up three homers. Hopefully the spacious A’s ballpark can help remedy that number a bit.
Former teammates, Scott Baker and Kevin Slowey have always been two favorites of mine mostly because of their great control. I love Baker at $5 if he can come back from this elbow tendinitis that’s been plaguing him this preseason. Slowey, on the other hand, has always been plagued by the long ball, but the move to Cleveland could help remedy the problem should he break camp in the rotation.
Jason Hammel is an interesting case this season as he finally leaves the hitter’s haven that is Coors Field. He has a career 4.18 xFIP and 4.67 FIP at home, but a 5.16 ERA. Now, Camden Yards isn’t a pitcher’s park and the AL East is a much tougher divisionl, but at $1 I’m willing to find out what kind of improvements a change of location brings.
Relief Pitchers
Mariano Rivera ($18), Fernando Rodney (R)
There’s the old adage that you should never pay for saves, but that’s a shallow league’s game. In a deep league, if you want to compete you better get a reliable closer and who better than Mariano Rivera who’s been saving games since 1997. You don’t get much safer than that and in this day and age where closers tend to drop like flies, it’s worth to pay for safe.
I don’t love Fernando Rodney, but he could sneak in some saves here and there in Tampa Bay. Kyle Farnsworth isn’t the most reliable pitcher in terms of health and Rodney has the most experience closing in that bullpen. In a league like this he makes for a decent second RP, especially if your top closer is as safe as Rivera.


