If you’ve been following along here at Baseball Professor, you might recall I profiled Dustin Ackley at the very end of December. Ackley ranked fifth in MLB.com’s 2011 Top 50 Prospects, but the Mariners also had another guy ranked right near the top. Checking in at number 13 is 22-year-old starting pitcher, Michael Pineda
After Felix Hernandez, Seattle doesn’t have much in their rotation – that is unless you consider Erik Bedard, Doug Fister, Luke French and Jason Vargas more than temporary stopgaps. Pineda is young, but Seattle needs him now.
And Pineda is talented enough to get a chance pretty soon. Since the Mariners don’t figure to be in contention this season, they’ll likely keep Pineda in the minors for a month or two to delay arbitration. That’s probably a smart move on two fronts: (1) why not have an extra year of control over a guy who could be your team’s next ace and (2) there’s no reason to rush a young pitcher to the big leagues out of spring training for a team that isn’t going to be any good. While those four replacement-level starters probably aren’t in Seattle’s long term plans (I don’t care how good Vargas seemed last year), they’re certainly good enough to eat up innings while the team weans Pineda into the rotation.
So, how good can Pineda be? Lookoutlanding.com did a very nice job profiling Pineda for both the 2011 season and beyond. While Pineda has demonstrated exceptional control for a young power pitcher (2.1 BB/9 in minors), he does have some trouble with left-handed batters. This comes from his lack of a true secondary out-pitch. Pineda has an exceptional fastball and is aggressive when throwing it, but his changeup and curveball are works in progress and at this point have not been wholly effective against left-handed batters. That article at Lookout Landing provides these splits:
vs. LHB: 3.5 BB/9, 9.4 K/9
vs. RHB: 1.6 BB/9, 12.3 K/9
Now the good news – Pineda gets to pitch in Safeco Field. We’ve long known that Safeco is a boon for pitchers (look what happened once Adrian Beltre left) but we can also break down the ballpark’s effects on both right- and left-handed batters individually. Note that for the following stats, 100 is league average. Over 100 benefits the hitter, under 100 benefits the pitcher:
(Hit Type: LHB/RHB)
Singles: 105/100
Doubles: 84/103
Triples: 60/97
Home Runs: 91/84
Safeco is extremely tough against left-handed batters when it comes to doubles and triples, and still very tough when it comes to homers (even though it’s tougher in this regard for right-handed batters). Pineda allowed a homer about every 18 innings in the minors (0.5 HR/9), so the added help keeping lefties off second and third base should only aid him where he struggles most.
But as good as Pineda is, he’s probably more of a fantasy sleeper in 2012. He’ll almost certainly start the year in the minors and Seattle will definitely monitor his innings throughout the whole season. He threw just 135.1 innings last year, and most clubs try to limit their young starters to 30 inning increases per year. That puts Pineda on track for around 160-165 innings for 2011, and a month or two in Triple-A will likely eat up nearly 40 innings. That puts Pineda on track for 120 innings with the Mariners at most, and he’ll probably fall a little short of that.
While Pineda’s good control rates and home ballpark make me optimistic about his ability to have an immediate impact (Mat Latos had a similar K:BB ratio in the minors, a power fastball and also pitches in a pitcher’s park) Seattle is in no rush to promote him. Keeper leagues should invest once he gets the call – and ideally right before – but Pineda’s value is limited in re-draft leagues. His WHIP figures to be low for a rookie and I could see him striking out 80-plus batters depending on how many innings he throws, but his win potential is low with the Mariners.
Since I like talking prospects, I’ll leave you with what Mariners GM Jack Zduriencik had to say about Pineda:
You’re talking about a 6-foot-5, 245-pound guy with a 100-mph fastball as a starting pitcher, which is very rare. He’s young, but he has all the earmarks of a top-of-the-order starter for years to come.
2011 Fantasy Projection
5-6 | 4.20 ERA | 1.25 WHIP | 100 K | 115 IP | 7.80 K/9
