Baseball Professor

Don't listen to the experts. Become the expert.

Reaction To Tristan H. Cockcroft’s Top 10

Tristan H. Cockcroft of recently published his early top 200 rankings for 2010.  He based his rankings on a 10 team league using Rotisserie 5×5 scoring.  I would like to share my views on his top 10 and open up the topic for discussion.

His top 10 were as follows:

1. Albert Pujols
2. Hanley Ramirez
3. Ryan Braun
4. Alex Rodriguez
5. Carl Crawford
6. Prince Fielder
7. Tim Lincecum
8. Chase Utley
9. Matt Kemp
10. Miguel Cabrera

Let’s start right at the top.  I think Hanley should be the first overall pick with Pujols going second.  Although Pujols puts up the best numbers in the game, Hanley puts up better numbers relative to his position.  First base is an incredibly deep position with proven mashers such as Prince Fielder, Miguel Cabrera, Ryan Howard, Mark Teixeira, Justin Morneau, and Adrian Gonzalez as well as up and coming sluggers such as Kendry Morales and Joey Votto.  Shortstop isn’t nearly as deep.  There’s a noticeable drop off after Jose Reyes, Troy Tulowitzki, Derek Jeter, and Jimmy Rollins.  Not to mention the top shortstops after Hanley aren’t as safe as the top first basemen after Pujols.  As a result, I think Hanley is the clear cut choice with the first overall pick.

Another problem I have with his list is that Crawford at 5 is too high.  Cockcroft has Crawford ranked as the second best outfielder.  However, I would much rather have Kemp.  They’ll both hit for roughly the same average and score just about the same number of runs.  Kemp should hit around 30 home runs again next year and is a lock for 100 RBI.  Crawford on the other hand will be in the 15-20 HR and 65-80 RBI range.  Although Crawford will steal between 50 and 60 bases, Kemp can more than hold his own totaling 34 last year and 35 the year before.  Kemp is also 5 years younger and is just about to enter his prime while Crawford has most likely peaked.

A final problem I have with Cockcroft’s top 10 is that I don’t believe Lincecum should be drafted in the first round.  Although Lincecum is the best pitcher on the board, pitchers generally carry more risk than elite hitters because they are more likely to have season threatening injuries, i.e. Johan Santana, Jake Peavy, and Brandon Webb.  Since early round picks are all about minimizing risk, I would feel a lot more comfortable taking someone like Evan Longoria over Tim Lincecum.

These are my thoughts on Tristan’s top 10.  Now the floor is yours.  What’s your top 10 next year?  Also, what does your top 10 look like in a keeper league?


Follow Us

Updated: December 20, 2011 — 12:53 am
  • Bryan Curley

    I won’t argue it too much because Fielder did drive in 141 runs and rebounded to hit 46 HR, but I think I like Miguel Cabrera more. He’s a pretty safe bet for a .315-.320 average, 35 HR and 115+ RBI. I’m not sold that Fielder is in that Ryan Howard RBI echelon.

  • George Fitopoulos

    You should be sold that Fielder is a 40+ HR guy and in the area of 120 RBI and I would take that over what Miggy brings to the table any day of the week even with an average in the .280’s.

    Plus, he’s huggable and Miggy might beat you.

  • Bryan Curley

    Haha well Miggy and the drinking/beating is worrisome, but if it comes down to Fielder hitting .280/40/120 and Cabrera hitting .320/35/120, then I take Cabrera. And yes he is a 120 RBI guy in Detroit. He had 127 in ’08 and finished ’09 with only 103, but he only had 20 in June and July combined.

  • FenwayPunk

    You can’t go wrong with either Pujols or Hanley at first pick, but the position scarcity arguement is for the birds. “Stat scarcity” is what you should be concered with. HR/RBI are harder to find than SB/Runs. Having Crawford ahead of Longoria in any draft is just plain silly. I get why Crawford is there though, contract year and yadda yadda. And yes Bryan; Fielder is most definatley in Ryan Howard’s echelon.

  • FenwayPunk

    *ahem* My top ten:
    1. Pujols
    2. Hanley
    3. A-rod
    4. Utley
    5. Braun
    6. Teixiera
    7. Fielder
    8. Howard
    9. Miggy
    10. Longo

Baseball Professor © 2016 Frontier Theme